US Midterm elections are tomorrow. In June, MF asked…
Your citation of Plato* fits well with things we’ve been reading: (a) Peter Turchin’s End Times examines long term cycles in which he highlights two dominant forces: the overproduction of elites and the resulting immiseration of the general population. (b) A related attempt to explain history comes from Benn Steil’s article on the inevitable failure of rule of law regimes. I would love to know your thoughts.
On (a), let’s do the economics. “Overproduction” means that supply is outpacing demand, so price will be dropping [see my post on failing university education]. Since the supply is of elites, then “price” means their “returns” (wages, income, prestige) are falling, which will lead to their anxiety and perhaps an attempt to “get their due” via political protest, popular manipulation or just straight war. This theory (revolution by the underemployed and overeducated) makes sense to me. How does this lead to immiseration? Besides the obvious (revolution is not good for the poors), elites will also take pre-revolutionary actions to raise themselves at a cost to the poors (e.g., restricting access to jobs to those with credentials) and/or pursue policies that benefit the few at a cost to the many — policies that the elites would not make if they felt they were getting the power and wealth they assumed as their rights.
On (b), “rule of law” is a good thing but you can have too much of a good thing if you rely ONLY on rule of law. That’s due to the problem of “incomplete contracts,” which means that [written] laws cannot cover all contingencies. Those need to be filled in with culture, common sense, and/or other rules of thumb. If done well (because institutions or “the rules of the game” are deep and agreed), then there’s no issue. If done poorly (because institutions are selectively ignored or misinterpreted — as seems to be happening at the US Supreme Court), then rule of law is meaningless. Trump’s abuse of pardons (issuing them for bribes, for unpopular offenders he likes, and inconsistently) is a good example of undermining rule of law. Buchanan and Tullock’s 1962 Calculus of Consent does a decent job of blending rule of law with common sense, but they assume a process pursued by good-intentioned leaders. That’s not true in the US today (and many countries and jurisdictions for decades), which is why many Americans are angry with each other, the world and their leaders.
Putting (a) and (b) together, there’s a good chance for a revolutionary uprising (democratic? violent?) by groups unhappy with how current laws are creating bad outcomes. Will those groups be united? powerful enough to overcome incumbents? We will see — perhaps as soon as tomorrow.
*Plato wrote “The measure of a man is what he does with power,” which is similar to what I’ve said for decades: Those with power should not abuse it. Alas, many with power do not read.