The UNESCO problem

Many countries and people are proud of their UNESCO-certified world heritage sites. There are over 1,200 in 170+ countries. About half of the sites are in Europe and about 75% of the sites are “cultural” and about 20% are “natural.” UNESCO certification means sites get more political attention, funds for conservation and the economic benefits from tourists.

But there’s a cloud in this silver-lining: a “frozen in amber” effect that can be counter-productive, especially as climate chaos makes it harder to maintain cultural sites built for a different climate:

  • The wrong insulation. Buildings in Amsterdam’s center have huge, single-pane glass windows. That means they consume more energy (or get more uncomfortable) in hotter or colder weather. Those windows cannot be replaced with double-glazed windows without violating UNESCO standards.
  • The wrong roofing material. The grey “tin” roofs of historical buildings in Paris heat up in summer. They cannot be painted white without violating UNESCO standards.
  • The wrong codes. UNESCO buildings cannot (AFAIK) be “modified” with holes to install heat (and cooling)  pumps, which are far more efficient and effective than old fashioned “protected” HVAC systems.
  • The wrong building. Some “UNESCO” areas include modern/ugly/badly built buildings from a different era than the era targeted by UNESCO, but those cannot be changed due to a blanket-ban on material changes in the protected area. (I saw this first-hand in Valparaiso, Chile.)
  • The wrong place. Climate chaos means that some place will be too hot, too dry, too flooded or too torn to pieces to stay inhabited. Humans have been moving from place to place for our entire history as a species. Sure, it’s good to put down roots and build enduring communities, but at some point it may be necessary to leave. New Orleans, Venice, Jakarta, and even Amsterdam are on my list of cities that will need to be abandoned with time. UNESCO status means they will stay inhabited (or be re-re-re-built for too long).

That’s just a short lists of problems off the top of my head. Ironically (!?), they are similar to the problems of “modern” buildings that pay zero attention to traditional architectural designs dating from before climate controlled buildings. As this 2019 article explains, air conditioning (and heating) has allowed lazy architects to copy/paste the same building in cities all over the world, without regard to local climate, the direction of the sun, elevation, etc.  This strategy maybe made sense when energy was cheap and climate chaos was unknown, but it “built facts on the ground” that will be locked in for generations of higher costs and lower comfort.

Bottom line: Climate chaos will force us to adapt, and the most important adaptations will be (a) rebuilding or retreating our cities and (b) making space for Nature to expand and spread — as a means of protecting us — over places that we’ve “reclaimed.” Hey UNESCO: If you’re not part of the solution, then you’re part of the problem.

Author: David Zetland

I'm a political-economist from California who now lives in Amsterdam.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.