
Last week, we killed another boat. It was my third. We “killed” these boats by taking them to the recycling center (another euphemism) where they were crushed by machines so the wood could go to the incinerator. Thus, we can also say that the boats are cremated.
Now, I have been thinking more about death as I get closer (statistically) to it. My father’s death last year was the book-end to my mother’s death 38 years ago. Death is universal, but we do not deal with it universally. Not surprisingly, plenty of people fear death as a process or result. That fear changes as you age, sometimes growing stronger, sometimes weaker. Philosophy and religion have a lot to say about death, mostly in helping us accept it.
Most people see premature death — by accident or disease — as a tragedy, as a “waste” of a life not lived. (I agree.) By symmetry, they see death in old age (“old” being a moving target) as normal, natural, acceptable — except perhaps by the person who is dying. I’ve seen both in the past year, and it’s really hard to say goodbye to someone whose time was not yet ripe.
People attach similar feelings to non-human death, like that of a pet or — and work with me here — a boat. If the pet dies of old age, we see it similarly to that of a human. If the pet is killed or dies while young, then it’s a loss, a tragedy. (I had cats who lived to 3 years and 18 years.)
Back to the boat. If it’s “fulfilled its duty” then we are less stressed about taking it to the breakers or the dumpsters. If it launches and sinks immediately, or if it sinks due to operator error, then it’s again a tragedy. But now we add a new dimension: consumption — or overconsumption — which leads not to early death by sinking, but early death by disposal. If you have too many boats to store and you need to get rid of one by taking it to the dumpsters, then it’s a tragedy not of “death” but “murder” of a boat that could continue to provide its services and pleasures… if only someone would take it over.
But we have too many boats, like we have too many clothes (and too much stuff in general — thus the boom in self-storage), so we’re constantly throwing away “perfectly good stuff”. It’s the same with cats, which leads to “cat ladies” who rescues cats from death (yay!) but then get buried in that responsibility (smells!). Those people cannot let go, but the fact that so many others are fine about it explains the ongoing, worse-in-the-US-than-other-places (correlated with human murder?) practice of “putting down” (murdering) pets, because supply exceeds demand.
It’s the same with boats, which are no longer as popular are they were.
When we were poorer, we would use a boat until it gave up. We’d repair it when it broke, we’d maintain it to maximize life, and so on. Now, it’s just “too much work” compared to other boats needing homes, and we throw them away. It’s the same with repairing clothes until they are “threadbare” switching to throwing them away because new is cheap and easy. It’s the same with old dogs and cats that nobody wants. They are passed over in favor of younger beasts. They are “put down.”
Some people see the increasing flow of waste as nothing special. I see it as a tragedy that is not at all the same as the premature death of a human, but definitely in the same realm of waste and loss.
Bottom line: Our emotions around loss are authentic signals of what is right or wrong in the world. We should not accept the casual destruction of boats, pets, clothes — and especially not humans — as “normal.”
RIP V-982, V-1500, V-unknown, and — soon — V-1513*
*I bought V-1513 in 2022 and sailed him (“Chance”) for four seasons. Then I bought V-521 because it was a better boat. Since nobody wants to buy 1513, I will have to take him to the dumpsters. It’s sad.
Apropos the material waste: I suspect one very effective solution is (a) to halt technical progress so that we stop developing better boats and (b) substantially raise the cost of making a new boat so that it is cost efficient to continue maintaining existing boats forever (much like happens in Cuba with automobiles*).
In the late 1960s, before the western opening to China but after the beginnings of the environmental movement, I recall reading paeans to Chinese reuse of material goods and the minimal waste that accumulated as a consequence. The image that has stuck with me is how, otherwise perfectly good incandescent light bulbs in which the filament had burnt out were not thrown out. Instead, the Chinese had factories for saving them, where the glass would be carefully drilled so that the filament could be replaced and then the glass patched. Something like this is economically possible only where the society is so poor that labor is essentially a free good.
I am not so much pro-waste or anti-environment as pro human flourishing and anti-poverty!
*If you are unfamiliar with Cuban car culture, ask Claude.
They have had a long habit of recycling cars or salvages cars since they can not obtain newer cars. Whatever you wish to call it. I saw some of them while stationed (8th Marines) in Cuba. That was in 1970.
I not sure what the point is of the 55 years of blockage since I was stationed there. Not much of a threat then or now.